Out of something? Swap it.
Honest cocktail substitutions — and exactly how each one changes the drink. No swap is ever identical, so we tell you the trade-off.
Spirits
Bourbon ↔ Rye whiskey
-
The other one, 1:1
Freely interchangeable in most stirred drinks. Rye is drier and spicier; bourbon is rounder and sweeter — adjust sugar to taste.
Cognac
-
Any decent brandy, 1:1
Armagnac or a solid grape brandy works. Avoid harsh bottom-shelf brandy in spirit-forward drinks.
Cachaça
-
White rhum agricole, 1:1
Closest match — both are fresh-cane spirits with that grassy funk.
-
White rum, 1:1
Cleaner and less funky (a Caipirinha becomes a Caipiroska in spirit).
Mezcal
-
Blanco tequila, 1:1
Same agave base, but you lose the smoke. Add a tiny drop of a peaty whisky if you want a smoky hint.
Absinthe (for a rinse)
-
Pernod or pastis
Any anise spirit gives the same aromatic glass rinse. Use sparingly — a rinse, not a pour.
Liqueurs & modifiers
Triple sec / Cointreau
-
Grand Marnier, 1:1
Richer and rounder (orange + cognac). Slightly sweeter, so dial back any added sugar.
-
Orange curaçao, 1:1
Very close; curaçao is a touch sweeter and may be colored.
Sweet vermouth
-
Ruby port + a dash of bitters
Adds the wine-y sweetness; bitters bring back the herbal edge. Not identical but works in a pinch.
Dry vermouth
-
Crisp dry white wine
Use a touch less — wine lacks vermouth's botanicals but covers the dryness.
-
Lillet Blanc
Softer and fruitier; the drink gets a little sweeter.
Campari
-
Any red bitter aperitivo, 1:1
Generic 'bitter rosso' liqueurs are made for exactly this.
-
Aperol, 1:1
Much lighter and sweeter, lower proof — the drink loses its bitter backbone.
Aperol
-
Campari + a little simple syrup
Campari is far more bitter and higher proof; sweeten and lengthen to approximate Aperol's softness.
Maraschino liqueur
-
A small dose of another cherry liqueur
No perfect swap — maraschino is dry and funky, most cherry liqueurs are sweeter. Use less and expect a sweeter result.
Coffee liqueur (Kahlúa)
-
Cold-brew concentrate + simple syrup
Roughly 2:1 coffee to syrup. Non-alcoholic, so the drink gets a touch weaker.
Crème de cassis
-
Chambord or another berry liqueur
Chambord (raspberry) is the easiest stand-in; the berry note shifts but the sweetness and color hold.
Citrus & juice
Fresh lime juice
-
Fresh lemon juice, 1:1
A real pinch-hitter — lemon is rounder and less sharp. Always fresh; bottled juice tastes flat and metallic.
Fresh lemon juice
-
Fresh lime juice, 1:1
Brighter and more acidic. Again — squeeze it fresh.
Grapefruit juice
-
Orange juice + a squeeze of lemon
Recreates the sweet-tart citrus balance when you have no grapefruit.
Syrups & sweeteners
Simple syrup
-
Equal parts sugar dissolved in hot water
It IS simple syrup — stir 1:1 sugar and warm water until clear, then cool. Two minutes, no excuse.
-
Superfine sugar, ~1 tsp per ½ oz
Shake well so it dissolves. Granulated may stay gritty in cold builds.
Rich (2:1) syrup
-
2 parts sugar : 1 part water
Sweeter and thicker than simple syrup, so it adds less water — use about ¾ the volume a recipe calls for in simple syrup.
Honey syrup
-
Honey stirred with warm water, 3:1
Neat honey won't mix into a cold drink; thin it first. Maple syrup is a (distinct) backup.
Orgeat (almond syrup)
-
Simple syrup + a drop of almond extract
Captures the almond note but not the silky body. Add a pinch of salt and orange-flower water if you have it.
Grenadine
-
Pomegranate juice simmered with sugar, 1:1
Real grenadine is just that. Pomegranate molasses + sugar also works — skip the neon bottled stuff.
Mixers & bubbles
Club soda / soda water
-
Seltzer or sparkling water, 1:1
Effectively identical fizz. Tonic is NOT neutral — it adds sugar and quinine bitterness.
Tonic water
-
Soda water + simple syrup + lime
Approximates the sweetness, but you can't fake quinine's bitter snap.
Ginger beer
-
Ginger ale + extra lime
Milder and sweeter — add lime to sharpen. Ginger syrup + soda gets closer to the spicy bite.
Champagne
-
Any dry sparkling wine
Cava, Prosecco or Crémant all top a cocktail beautifully and cost far less.
Other
Egg white
-
Aquafaba (chickpea brine), ¾ oz per white
Whips to the same silky foam and is vegan. Dry-shake it the same way.
No match — try another ingredient, or check the finder.
Missing a bottle entirely? The cocktail finder shows what you can make with what you already have — and what you're one ingredient away from.
Substitution FAQ
Can I substitute lime juice for lemon juice?
Yes, 1:1 in a pinch — lemon is rounder and less sharp than lime, so the drink shifts a little but stays balanced. Always use fresh juice; bottled tastes flat.
What can I use instead of triple sec or Cointreau?
Grand Marnier (richer, slightly sweeter) or orange curaçao both work 1:1. Any orange liqueur covers the role.
What's a substitute for simple syrup?
Make it — stir equal parts sugar into warm water until clear, then cool. In a cold shake you can also use superfine sugar, about 1 tsp per ½ oz.
Is there a vegan substitute for egg white in cocktails?
Aquafaba (the brine from a can of chickpeas) whips to the same silky foam. Use about ¾ oz per egg white and dry-shake it the same way.